نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
Climate change and the need to reduce energy consumption in buildings have intensified interest in architectural approaches that respond to local environmental conditions. Within this context, vernacular architecture has gained prominence in energy efficiency research because of its climate-responsive strategies and the accumulated knowledge embodied in traditional building practices. Its relevance extends beyond preserving architectural heritage to informing contemporary discussions about thermal comfort, environmental performance, and sustainable design. Nevertheless, understanding this expanding research field requires more than documenting publication growth or identifying frequently occurring concepts. Bibliometric patterns reveal the visibility and interconnectedness of research topics, but they do not independently explain the epistemological structure of knowledge production or distinguish the levels at which studies contribute to the field.
This study therefore aims to map the research landscape of vernacular architecture and energy efficiency, identify emerging thematic directions, and examine how selected studies are distributed across the levels of the paradigm funnel. By combining bibliometric analysis with qualitative epistemological classification, the study connects the observable structure of scientific publications with the character of their contributions. This integrated perspective addresses a limitation of approaches that rely exclusively on publication frequencies, keyword co-occurrence, or conceptual networks. Rather than treating all publications as equivalent units of knowledge production, it considers whether their contributions occupy different positions within a broader epistemological framework.
Relevant records were retrieved from Scopus using selected keywords covering vernacular architecture and energy efficiency. The search period extended from 2021 to March 2026, defining the temporal scope within which the development of the field was examined. The identification and screening process followed the PRISMA reporting framework to provide a structured account of record selection. Following this process, 492 articles were included in the bibliometric analysis. From this collection, 85 articles were selected for qualitative classification. Their titles, abstracts, research methods, and findings provided the basis for examining their epistemological orientation and assigning them within the analytical framework. The qualitative subset thus supported a closer examination of knowledge contributions than could be obtained from bibliographic indicators alone.
The selected articles were examined across four epistemological levels of the paradigm funnel. Review articles were treated as a separate study category rather than being designated as a fifth level. This distinction maintained the separation between an article’s study category and its position within an epistemological hierarchy. Bibliometric analyses were conducted using VOSviewer and the Bibliometrix package in R, enabling examination of the field’s conceptual structure and thematic patterns. The qualitative component complemented these analyses by focusing on the distribution of contributions across the funnel. Together, the two components offered different but related perspectives: one addressed the organization and prominence of research themes, while the other examined the epistemological positioning of selected studies.
The bibliometric findings identified “thermal comfort,” “thermal performance,” and “sustainability” as central concepts in the research landscape. Their prominence indicates that investigations of vernacular architecture remain closely connected to questions of indoor environmental conditions, building performance, and broader sustainability objectives. These concepts provide a thematic foundation for understanding how vernacular strategies are discussed in relation to contemporary energy challenges. At the same time, the analysis revealed changes in the visibility of emerging topics. The recorded frequency of “biophilic design” increased from 1 to 40 over the study period, indicating growing attention to this concept within the analyzed literature. This change should be understood as a bibliometric observation rather than direct evidence of the effectiveness or maturity of associated design approaches.
The qualitative classification showed that Level 2 accounted for the largest proportion of the subset, with 32 articles representing 37.65% of the 85 selected studies. This concentration highlights an uneven distribution of epistemological contributions within the examined sample. Importantly, the result refers to the qualitative subset and should not automatically be generalized to all 492 articles included in the bibliometric analysis. The distribution nevertheless provides a basis for considering how the field develops knowledge and where further investigation may be needed. Artificial intelligence and biophilic design were identified as potential future research directions, suggesting opportunities to examine how emerging approaches might interact with established climate-responsive knowledge without assuming that novelty alone constitutes epistemological advancement.
Overall, the study demonstrates the analytical value of integrating bibliometric mapping with the paradigm funnel. The combined approach supports a simultaneous examination of conceptual prominence, emerging themes, and the distribution of epistemological contributions. It thereby moves beyond describing what is frequently published to considering how knowledge is produced and positioned. Its interpretation remains bounded by the Scopus dataset, the selected keywords, the study period, and the qualitative subset. Within these boundaries, the findings provide a structured basis for identifying research gaps that may remain obscured by publication counts and keyword networks alone. This perspective can inform future research agendas seeking a clearer relationship between vernacular architectural knowledge, energy efficiency, and the development of more conceptually balanced scholarship.
کلیدواژهها English