ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
Conceptualization Methods in the Design Process of Architecture
One of the most exciting periods for architectural designers in design research is the time in which design ideas turn into a major design concept. This period is called “conceptualization” and it may occur differently in different projects. Studies show that there are several levels of idealization involved in developing a design concept. Many basic ideas related to each goal of the designer for his/her project contribute to the development of the most comprehensive concept which is called a design “parti”. This article takes a close look at the subject of conceptualization in the design process of architecture. There are two main sections which form the structure of this article. The first section, using descriptive as well as analytic methods, introduces the two most regarded design process approaches in architecture: the step by step approach also called “systematic”, and the interactive approach called “environmental”. This section also reviews four major design methods frequently used by architects. They are called: analogic, typologic, pragmatic, and theoretic methods. The second section, using survey method, investigates the relation between the design process and design methods used by 30 grade-one architectural consultants in Tehran and 350 undergraduate students of architecture at different universities in Iran. As far as the function of the projects, the three most applied functions were chosen as: residential, office/commercial, and educational projects. In order to investigate about the preference of each group in using design process and design methods in each of the three categories, some questionnaires were developed and collected from the professional group as well as the student group. The responses of the participants were analyzed by SMART-PLS software. The results of the research indicate that both groups of professionals and students tend to use more “systematic” approach in their design process, and “pragmatic” design method in their projects. In an analytic view, one could compare the preferred design process and design methods used in each group: In the students group: In residential projects: there is a desire to use “systematic” approach with “pragmatic” method, “collaborative” approach with “analogic” method, and “interactive” approach with “theoretic” and “analogic” methods. In office/commercial projects: there is a meaningful relation between “systematic” approach and “pragmatic” and “typologic” methods, “collaborative” approach and “analogic” method, and “interactive” approach and “analogic and “theoretic” methods. In educational projects: there is a meaningful relation between the “systematic” approach and “pragmatic” method, “interactive” approach with “theoretic” method, and “collaborative “approach and “typologic” method. In the professional consultants group: In residential projects: there is a desire to use “systematic” approach with “analogic” and “pragmatic” methods, “collaborative” approach with “analogic” and “pragmatic” methods, and “”interactive” approach with “theoretic” and “analogic” methods. In office/commercial projects: there is a meaningful relation between “systematic” approach and “analogic” and “pragmatic” methods, “collaborative” approach with “analogic” and “typologic” and “pragmatic” methods, and “interactive” approach with “analogic” method. In educational projects: there is a meaningful relation between “collaborative” approach with “analogic” method, “interactive” approach with “analogic” and “theoretic” methods, and “systematic” approach with “pragmatic” and “typologic” methods.
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_67904_4ed8d37f5d7c4827557373b7634536db.pdf
2018-05-22
5
18
10.22059/jfaup.2018.238916.671776
Keywords: Design process
Idea and concept
Analogic Method
Typologic Method
Pragmatic Method
Theoretic Method
AMIR SAEID
MAHMOODI
amahmood@ut.ac.ir
1
Iran - ‎Faculty member at School of Architecture, University of Tehran
LEAD_AUTHOR
Mahyar
Bastani
bastanimahyar@gmail.com
2
Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad university
AUTHOR
آنتونیادس، آنتونیسی (1393)، بوطیقای معماری(آفرینش در معماری)، ترجمه احمدرضا آی، انتشارات سروش، تهران.
1
اسلامی، غلامرضا (1392)، درسگفتار مبانی نظری معماری: عینکمان را خودمان بسازیم، پژوهشکده هنر، تهران.
2
الکساندر، کریستوفر (1392)، سرشت نظم ساختارهای زنده در معماری، ترجمه رضا سیروس صبری و علی اکبری، پرهام نقش، تهران.
3
پناهی، سیامک؛ رحیم هاشم پور و سید غلامرضا اسلامی (1393)، معماری اندیشه، از ایده تا کانسپت، نشریه هویت شهر، دوره 8، شماره 17، صص 25-34.
4
دورک، دانا پی (1393)، برنامهدهی معماری، مدیریت اطلاعات برای طراحی، ترجمه امیرسعید محمودی، انتشارات دانشگاه تهران، تهران.
5
رضایی، محمود (1393)، آنالوطیقای طراحی، بازنگری انگارهها در فرآیند طراحی فرم و فضای معاصر، انتشارات دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی واحد تهران مرکزی، تهران.
6
لاوسون برایان (1384)، طراحان چگونه میاندیشند، ابهامزدایی از فرآیند طراحی، ترجمه حمید ندیمی، مرکز چاپ و انتشارات دانشگاه شهید بهشتی، تهران.
7
لنگ، جان (1386)، آفرینش نظریه معماری، نقش علوم رفتاری در طراحی محیط، ترجمه علیرضا عینیفر، انتشارات دانشگاه تهران، تهران.
8
محمودی، امیرسعید (1383)، تفکر در طراحی، معرفی الگوی تفکر تعاملی در آموزش طراحی، مجله هنرهای زیبا، شماره20، صص27-36.
9
مسعود، محمد؛ شاهد ولید مغربی و سمیرا سادات حسینی یزدی(1390)، نقش تمثیل در روند طراحی معماری، مجله صفه، دوره 21، شماره 2، صص 33-42.
10
معماریان، غلامحسین و محمدعلی طبرسا (1391)، گونه و گونهشناسی معماری، نشریه علمی پژوهشی انجمن علمی معماری و شهرسازی ایران، دوره 6، شماره3، صص243-255.
11
نسبیت، کیت (1391)، نظریههای پسامدرن در معماری، ترجمه محمدرضا شیرازی، نشر نی، تهران.
12
ندیمی، حمید (1378)، جستاری در فرآیند طراحی، مجله صفه، دوره 9، شماره 29، صص 95-103.
13
ندیمی، حمید و فرهاد شریعتراد (1391)، منابع ایدهپردازی معماری، جستاری در فرآیند ایدهپردازی چند معمار از جامعه حرفهای کشور، نشریه هنرهای زیبا-معماری و شهرسازی، دوره 17، شماره 2، صص 5-14.
14
وایت، ادوارد تی (1382)، مفاهیم پایه در معماری: واژگان فرمهای معماری، ترجمه محمد احمدینژاد، نشر خاک، تهران.
15
وورت، وندر و ون وگان(1392)، معماری کیفیتگرا، درآمدی بر برنامهریزی، طراحی و ارزیابی کیفیت عملکردی، ترجمه مهیار باستانی، کتابکده کسری، مشهد.
16
هادیان، محمد و حسنعلی پورمند (1393)، طرحمایه در معماری: یک ضرورت در فرآیند طراحی و چالشهای آموزش آن در دانشکدههای معماری، فصلنامه هنرهای کابردی، دوره 3، شماره 4، صص 73-80.
17
Abel, Chris (1988), Analogical Models in Architecture and Urban Design, METU JFA, 8(2), pp 161-188.
18
AIA National (2007), Integrated Project Delivery: A Guide, AIA California Council. United States of America.
19
Alexander, Christopher (1979), The Timeless Way of Building, Oxford University Press, New York.
20
Alexander, Christopher (1977), A pattern Language, Oxford University Press, New York.
21
Broadbent, G (1973), Methodology in the service of delight, In Proceedings of the 4th Annual Conference of Environmental Design Research Association-EDRA, pp 314-318.
22
Darke, J (1979), The Primary Generator and the Design Process, Design Studies, 1(1), pp. 36-44.
23
De Vries, Marc J; N. Cross & D.P.Grant (1993), Design Methodology and Relationships with Science, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands.
24
Durand, Jean-Nicolas-Louis (2000), Précis of the Lectures on Architecture, translation by David Britt, Getty research Institute, Los Angeles.
25
Gordon, W.J.J (1961). Synectics, the development of creative capacity, Harper & Row, New York.
26
Hearn, Millard F (2003), Idea that shaped Buildings, The MIT Press, Massachusetts.
27
Jencks, Charles (2002), The New Paradigm in Architecture: The Language of Postmodernism, Yale University Press; Netherlands.
28
Laseau, P (1980), Graphic Thinking for Architects and Designers, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.
29
Mahmoodi, Amir S (2001), The Design Process in Architecture: A pedagogic Approach Using Interactive Thinking, Ph.D Thesis, University of Leeds, U.K.
30
Pena, William P & Parshall, Steven A (2001), Problem seeking an architectural programming primer, John Wiley and Sons, New York.
31
Jormakka, K & Schurer, O (2007), Basic design methods, Birkhauser Architecture, Berlin.
32
Quatremère de Quincy, Antoine-Chrysostome (2000), The Historical Dictionary of Architecture , Papadakis Publisher, London.
33
Rapoport, Amos (1969), House, Form and Culture, Prentice_Hall, London.
34
Restrepo, J & Christiaans, H (2004), Problem Structuring and Information Access in Design, Journal of Design Research, 4(2), pp 218-236.
35
Rowe, P. G (1991), Design thinking, MIT press, Massachusetts.
36
Salama, Ashraf (1995), New Trends in Architectural Education: Designing the Design Studio. Raleigh, N.C.: Tailored Text and Unlimited Potential Publishing, United States of America.
37
Snyder, J. C; Catanese, A. J & MacGinty, T (1979), Design and the Design Process. In T.MacGinty (Ed), Introduction to architecture, McGraw-Hill, United States of America.
38
Steadman, J.P & Mitchell, L.J (2010), Architectural morphospace: mapping worlds of built forms, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 37(2), pp 197-220.
39
Steadman, J.P (2008), The evolution of designs: biological analogy in architecture and the applied arts, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
40
Wingardh, Gert & Wærn, Rasmus (2008), Crucial Words: Conditions for Contemporary Architecture, Birkhäuser GmbH.
41
ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
Factors of Environmental Assessment of Buildings in Residential Complexes, Using the Existing Building Performance Assessment Tools
Development of a relationship between nature and human needs can be found on literature of environmental performance assessment systems. The purpose of these systems is directed towards environmentally sensitive buildings. However, It should be noted that implementation of such tools in explaining the environmental goals of every ecological systems has been challenging so far. Checklist-based approach to environmental issues regardless of differences in economic, social, technological, environmental and institutional conditions of each region would not play a constructive role in this field. The current study seeks to explain factors of enhancing environmental conditions in residential complexes, relying on literature reviews and scholars views in Iran. In this way, measurements, approaches and criteria of eight building performance assessment systems in relation to subject of the study have been analyzed. According to the focus of the research on residential complexes, research and systems on the issue of residential buildings was selected. In cases of Inaccessibility to the system, the authors analyzed them in accordance with other relevant studies and secondary sources of information and measures. In these cases comparative studies of more than one source have been employed. Based on information obtained from literature review, interviews were conducted with scholars to deduce determining environmental factors of construction on residential complexes in Iran. After introducing purposes of the study and areas of queries, the interviewees presented scope, trends and emphasis in a non-directive approach. Then, in second interviews using semi-structured methods, a basis for developing and modifying parameters and components of the research was provided. By qualitative content analysis of interviews and literature review, theoretical framework and research hypotheses were formulated. The theoretical framework led the authors measure the relationship between latent and apparent variables of the study. Hypotheses are: 1) Factor of Stakeholders’ Synergy in Program is the main cause of enhancing Environmental Performance of buildings. 2) Factor of stakeholders’ synergy in program with mediation of Efficiency, Habitability and Durability affects Environmental Performance of buildings. 3) There are statistically significant relationship among mediators of Efficiency, Habitability and Durability. The research has been in the field of correlation methods on quantitative survey. Forming the theoretical framework and hypotheses, the research instrument (questionnaire) and the population were formulated. The first group of 15 consulting engineers company was selected according to the programming and design of residential complexes having related experience of the subject. The second group of researchers was in master or doctoral programs at universities of Tehran with related field of research. Enhancing environmental performance of buildings as the scope of assessment is a function of stakeholders synergy in architectural program, performance of buildings (contains variables of manufacturing efficiency, operational efficiency, cost feedback and performance feedback (, habitability of environment (contains variables of indoor environmental comfort, accessibility and sociability of outdoor spaces) and durability of buildings (contains variables of building maintenance, adaptation and improvement of the surrounding environment). Experimental results showed that there is a causal relationship between concepts of the theoretical framework, (hypothesis).
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_68045_45ec75c47fa0f096ba3b48c067312003.pdf
2018-05-22
19
30
10.22059/jfaup.2018.238430.671765
environment
Sustainable building
Building performance assessment
residential complex
M.Ali
Nemati
m.ali.nemati@gmail.com
1
Department of Architecture, Firouzabad Institute of Higher Education, Firouzabad, Fars, Iran.
LEAD_AUTHOR
Mohammad Reza
Bemanian
bemanian@modares.ac.ir
2
Professor, Department of Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
AUTHOR
Mojtaba
Ansari
ansari_m@modares.ac.ir
3
Associate Professor, Department of Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
AUTHOR
آذر، عادل؛ غلامزاده، رسول و قنواتی، مهدی (1391)، مدلسازی مسیری ساختاری در مدیریت، کاربرد نرمافزار SmartPLS، انتشارات نگاه دانش، تهران.
1
اکرمی، غلامرضا و دامیار، سجاد، (1396)، رویکردی نو به معماری بومی در رابطه ساختاری آن با معماری پایدار، هنرهای زیبا-معماری و شهرسازی، دوره 21، شماره 1، صص 29-39.
2
ایرانمنش، محسن و خواجهپور، الهام (1393)، آموزش معماری پایدار یا آموزش پایدار معماری، هنرهای زیبا- معماری و شهرسازی، دوره 19، شماره 1، صص 83-92.
3
جهانبخش، حیدر (1389)، تدوین الگوی برنامهدهی و روششناسی طراحی معماری پایدار در ایران، رساله دکتری معماری. دانشگاه علم و صنعت ایران.
4
داوری، علی و رضازاده، آرش (1395)، مدلسازی معادلات ساختاری با نرمافزار PLS، انتشارات جهاد دانشگاهی واحد تهران، تهران.
5
ضرغامی، اسماعیل (1389)، اصول پایداری اجتماعی مجتمع های مسکونی، رساله دکتری معماری، دانشگاه علم و صنعت ایران.
6
کاملنیا، حامد (1387)، معماری و الگووارههای طراحی جمعی، رساله دکتری معماری، دانشگاه تهران.
7
کلانتری خلیل آباد، حسین؛ کاظمی، سید محمد؛ حیدری، علی اکبر؛ طباطباییان، مریم و حقی، مهدی (۱۳۹۵)، فناوری های بومی و معماری همساز با اقلیم، نقش جهان، دوره ۶، شماره ۱، صص ۶۵-۷۹.
8
مفیدی شمیرانی، مجید و مضطرزاده، حامد (1393)، تدوین معیارهای ساختار محلات شهری پایدار، باغ نظر، دوره 11، شماره 29، صص 59-70.
9
Bakar, A. A; Osman, M. M; Bachok, S & Ibrahim, M (2015), An Exploratory Review: Human Interdependence with Environment, In Asia Pacific International Conference on Environment-Behaviour Studies, ???????????
10
Barclay, D; Higgins, C & Thompson, R (1995), The partial least squares (PLS) approach to causal modeling: Personal computer adoption and use as an illustration Technology studies, Special Issue on Research Methodology, Vol. 2, No. 2, 1995, pp. 285-309.
11
Ding, Grace K C (2008), Sustainable construction: The role of environmental assessment tools, Journal of Environmental Management, 86(3), pp.451–464.
12
Du Plessis, Chrisna (2005), Action for sustainability: Preparing an African plan for sustainable building and construction, Building Research & Information, 33(5): 405-415.
13
Gan, X; Fernandez, I. C; Guo, J; Wilson, M; Zhao, Y; Zhou, B & Wu, J (2017), When to use what: Methods for weighting and aggregating sustainability indicators, Ecological Indicators, 81, pp.491-502.
14
Haapio, Appu and Viitaniemi, Pertti (2008), A critical review of building environmental assessment tools, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 28(7), pp.469–482.
15
He, B; Han, Y; Zhao, L & Shen, L (2017), A Comparison Study on the Green Building Performance Assessment Tools for Promoting Sustainable Construction, In Proceedings of the 20th International Symposium on Advancement of Construction Management and Real Estate, Springer Singapore, 1169-1184.
16
Li, Z; Han, Y & Xu, P (2014), Methods for benchmarking building energy consumption against its past or intended performance: An overview, Applied Energy, 124, pp.325-334.
17
Schweber, L & Haroglu, H (2014), Comparing the fit between BREEAM assessment and design processes, Building Research & Information, 42(3), pp.300-317.
18
Shari, Z & Soebarto, V (2015), Comparative Review of Existing Building Performance Assessment Systems: Appropriateness for the Context of Emerging/Developing Countries. ALAM CIPTA, International Journal of Sustainable Tropical Design Research and Practice, 8(1), pp.1-12.
19
Wong, S. C & Abe, N (2014), Stakeholders' perspectives of a building environmental assessment method: The case of CASBEE, Building and Environment, 82, pp.502-516.
20
Zabihi, Hossein; Farah Habib, and Leila Mirsaeedie (2012), Sustainability assessment criteria for building systems in Iran, Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research, Vol. 11, No. 10, pp.1346-1351.
21
Zuo, J & Zhao, Z. Y (2014), Green building research–current status and future agenda: A review, Renewable and sustainable energy reviews, 30, 271-281.
22
ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
Modeling the city’s image in order to determine the priorities of city branding
case study: Urmia City
City’s competitiveness and attractiveness depend on effective management of the city’s image. Leading cities in the world have always used different approaches in order to improve their image. One of these modern approaches is city branding. Many cities in countries ranging from India and China to Russia and England have employed this approach in order to improve their image. In a world where cities and regions aggressively compete for investment from public and private sectors, brand reputation is critical. The motivation for cities to engage in city branding frequently stems from a feeling that existing perceptions of the city have become outdated and need to be updated in order to reflect the contemporary reality of the city. Repositioning the city brand is often seen as necessary and urgent. Indeed, a brand is the DNA of a place, i.e., its material and essence which pass from one generation to another. Today, many cities attempt to use city branding concepts to find a niche in the competition for resources and wealth. Like many other cities in Iran, Urmia City doesn’t project a strong and clear image to its dwellers and beyond. Most of its cultural, historical and natural features have been neglected. Anonymity of these features causes Urmia City to encounter problems in attracting investment and tourists, losing the competition to cities with stronger image. The main purpose of this paper is to model an image for the Urmia City based on the concepts pertaining to city branding. Since a city brand needs to be rooted in reality, the starting point for an effective and inclusive branding strategy, would be a search for the elements which the city has to offer to its current and potential residents, as well as the visitors and investors. It also needs to tap its unique assets and strengths and to address its flaws and weaknesses. Here after a review of the theories associated with city branding and its relation to city image, a theoretical was developed. This framework provided us with nine components and 46 criteria to be used in the analysis of the Urmia City’s image. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was used in order to identify the components and the criteria which influence the City’s image the most. Finally, priority of actions in Urmia City branding is determined and suggestions are presented. Results show that, Urmia city needs strategies which can upgrade its urban facilities and infrastructure along other measures that deal with its unique history, culture as well as its location on the border with Turkey to the west. In addition, the City’s strong environmental quality and natural features need to be emphasized in the strategies and action plans for the sake of the City’s image. In our findings, we can also note that the City's dwellers have a negative view of its economy and job opportunities, while the life style and social Issues are not much of an issue in formation of the City’s image.
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_67906_8a2684283ec6e96312853712f0cb64af.pdf
2018-05-22
31
40
10.22059/jfaup.2018.223153.671591
City Branding
City Image
Structural Equation Modeling
Urmia city
farshad
nourian
fnoorian@ut.ac.ir
1
Associate Professor, School of urban planning, College of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
LEAD_AUTHOR
mehdi
mikaeili
mehdimikaeili77@gmail.com
2
کارشناس ارشد برنامه ریزی شهری دانشگاه تهران
AUTHOR
آذر، عادل (1381)، تحلیل مسیر (Path analysis) و علتیابی در علم مدیریت، مجله مجتمع آموزش عالی قم، سال چهارم، شماره پانزدهم، زمستان 1381، صص 96-59.
1
Anholt, S (2006), The Anholt-GMI city brands index how the world sees the world's cities, Place branding, 2(1), pp.18-31.
2
Ashworth, G & Kavaratzis, M (2009), Beyond the logo: Brand management for cities, Journal of Brand Management, 16(8), pp.520-531.
3
Ashworth, G (2009), The instruments of place branding: How is it done? European Spatial research and policy, 16(1), pp.9-22.
4
Byrne, B. M (2012), A primer of LISREL: Basic applications and programming for confirmatory factor analytic models, Springer Science & Business Media.
5
Cities, E (2010), A shared vision on city branding in Europe, Retrieved from http://www.eurocities.eu/eurocities/documents/A-Shared-Vision-on-City-Branding-in-Europe-WSPO-8PLFNF.
6
Dinnie, K (2011), City branding: Theory and cases, Palgrave Macmillan, London, UK.
7
Hildreth, J (2008), The European City Brand Barometer–Revealing which cities get the brands they deserve, Saffron Brand Consultants, London.
8
Kavaratzis, M (2004), From city marketing to city branding: Towards a theoretical framework for developing city brands, Place Branding, 1(1), pp.58-73.
9
Kavaratzis, M & Ashworth, G. J (2005), City branding: an effective assertion of identity or a transitory marketing trick? Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie, 96(5), pp.506-514.
10
Maruyama, G (1998), Basics of structural equation modeling, Sage Publications, Inc. Thousand Oaks, CA.
11
Minghui, Q (2009), A study of success factors in city branding: the ISE conceptual model, Marketin Science Innovations and Economic Development, pp.313-321.
12
Moghaddam, M. S; Assadollahzadeh, T; Mirmoini, M & Azimi, S (2013), Examining the City Brand Theory and Presenting Some Solutions for Implementing of It in Iran, Civil Engineering and Architecture, 1(4), pp.120-124.
13
Pilenska, V (2012), City branding as a tool for urban regeneration: towards a theoretical framework, Architecture and Urban Planning, Vol.6, pp.12-16.
14
Prophet Consultancy (2006), CEOs for Cities. Branding your city, a guidebook for city leaders.
15
Rizzi, P & Dioli, I (2010), From strategic planning to city branding: Some empirical evidence in Italy, PASOS, 8 (3), pp.39-49.
16
Rehan, R. M (2014), Urban branding as an effective sustainability tool in urban development, HBRC Journal, 10(2), pp.222-230.
17
Zenker, S & Martin, N (2011), Measuring success in place marketing and branding, Place Branding and Public Diplomacy, 7(1), pp.32-41
18
Zhang, L & Zhao, S. X (2009), City branding and the Olympic effect: A case study of Beijing, Cities, 26(5), pp.245-254.
19
ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
Check the quality of the security permeability edge of space
(Case study: spatial analysis Timcheh structure in traditional Bazar)
In the historical form of the cities of Iran, the Bazzar is considered as an integral part of the city's structure which has formed the core and the main axis of the city and has guided the bones and development of the city. On the other hand, due to the economic role of the Bazzar in the city, the issue of security has been of particular importance. Therefore, it seems that the builders of this kind of buildings have special attention to their physical aspects in order to achieve this goal. For example, the establishment of Qaisarra as a space for the supply of valuable goods in the central Bazzar segment could be a effect in securing these usages. In this regard, it seems that the qualities of the edges of the Bazzar can also have a significant effect on this. Accordingly, the present study by investigates and analyzes various edges in the area around the Bazzar, examines the level of security in these spaces. On the other hand, Timcheh’s space was selected as a case study from among the various spaces available on the Bazzar. Therefore, the present study, while analyzing the permeability quality of the outer edges of several Timches, as part of the Bazzar space, addresses the issue of security in this type of space. In this research, space syntax technique has been used to analyze the configuration of the space of the towns. However, it is necessary to note that this technique is generally used to analyze the spatial structure of environments that consist of several small spaces. While the Timches in their physical structure are composed of spaces such as store, resting place, cellar, courtyards, corridors, entrances, Hashti, and so on. This justifies the application of this technique in the analysis of this kind of construction. After reviewing the literature, three indicators including “readablity”, “visual control and access”, and “space integration” were considered as theoretical framework of the research and tools like “Step depth”, “Integration”, “Connectivity”, “Physical accessibility(Metric depth)”, “Isovist area”, and “Isovist perimeter” were used to analyze them in the Depthmap software environment. The results of the study showed that the impermeable Timcheh in terms of readability index is in a desirable level, and due to having only one input, it is possible to control the entrance and exit of individuals. However, the four-directional permeable Timcheh in term of control and spatial integration indicator are at a higher level than the other Timches this has a significant impact on the security of these Timches. Also, the edge properties of the input (s) are more important in providing space security. Because it determines the amount of accumulated load to space and thus the permeability to space. The location of the Timches is one of the other things that have a significant impact on their security and their creation of crime scenes. Moreover, the presence of concave geometries in the space structure leads to inadequate visual visibility and the possibility of a massive increase in space.
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_67907_a6561133ca88e8d826a78d6b861c67f4.pdf
2018-05-22
41
54
10.22059/jfaup.2017.210451.671434
the way
Space
security
Bazar
Timcheh
Aliakbar
Heidari
aliakbar_heidari@iust.ac.ir
1
Faculty Member of Yasooj Islamic Azad University, Yasooj, Iran.
AUTHOR
Yaghowb
Peyvastegar
peyvastehgar@gmail.com
2
Faculty Member of Yasooj Islamic Azad University, Yasooj, Iran
LEAD_AUTHOR
مریم
کیایی
maryam.kiaee@qiau.ac.ir
3
پژوهشگر دکتری معماری دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی واحد یاسوج
AUTHOR
ایراندوست، کیومرث و بهمنی اورامانی، آرمان (1390)، تحولات بازار سنتی در شهرهای ایران (مطالعهی موردی: بازار شهر کرمانشاه)، مطالعات شهر ایرانی اسلامی، شماره 5، صص 5-14.
1
بلاغـی، عبدالحجـه (1386)، گزیـده تاریـخ تهـران، ؟؟؟؟، تهران.
2
بنتلی، ای ین؛ الکک، آلن؛ مورین، پال؛ مکگین، سو؛ لسمیت،گراهام (1393)، محیطهای پاسخده (کتاب راهنمای طراحان)، انتشارات دانشگاه علم و صنعت، تهران.
3
پورجعفر، علی و صداریی، امیر (1393)، تحلیل تطبیقی تیمچههای با فضای مرکزی غیرمسقف به عنوان فضاهای شهری تجاری در بازار با تاکید بر ویژگیهای تیمچه صرافیان در استان فارس، مدیریت شهری، شماره40، صص 7-21.
4
پیرنیا، محمد کریم، (1387)، آشنایی با معماری اسلامی ایران، نشر سروش دانش، تهران.
5
حبیب، فرح؛ عباسی، زهرا؛ مختاباد، سید مصطفی (1394)، تدوین اصول و معیارهای ادراک فضایی در معماری بازارهای سنتی ایران، مدیریت شهری، شماره 39، صص291-316.
6
حسینی، آرزو و پورنادری، حسین (1393)، مطالعهی تطبیقی فضای معماری کاروانسراهای صفوی در بازار اصفهان مطالعهی موردی: کاروانسرای شاه، ساروتقی، مادر شاه، مطالعات تطبیقی هنر، سال4، شماره 8، صص 81-97.
7
رهایی، امید (1393)، هویت فرهنگی و اثرات آن بر روشهای بومی تهویة طبیعی بازار قدیم دزفول، راسته صنعتگران، باغ نظر، شماره 24، سال 39، صص 10-46.
8
ریسمانچیان و امید، بل، سایمون (1390)، بررسی جدا افتادگی فضایی با فتهای فرسوده در ساختار شهر تهران به روش چیدمان فضا، باغ نظر، سال هشتم، شماره17، 69-80
9
ریسمانچیان، امید؛ پوردیهیمی، شهرام؛ دیدهبان، محمد(1392)، رابطهی بین "ویژگیهای شناختی" و"پیکره بندی" فضایی محیط مصنوع، تجربهای در دزفول، مطالعات معماری ایران، شمارهی4، صص ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟.
10
ساربان قلی ستاری، حسن و جدایی، امیر (1390)،بررسی و تحلیل طرحهای کاربندی بهکاررفته در تیمچههای بازار تبریز، مطالعات شهر ایرانی اسلامی، شماره 5، صص 29-46.
11
سرایی، محمد حسین (1389)، تحولات بازارهای ایرانی اسلامی(مطالعهی موردی بازار یزد)، مطالعات شهر ایرانی اسلامی، شماره2، صص 25-37.
12
عباسزادگان، مصطفی (1381)، طراحی شهری: روش چیدمان فضا در فرایند طراحی شهری با نگاهی به شهر یزد، مدیریت شهری، شماره 9، صص 64-.75
13
عباسزادگان، مصطفی و آذری، عباس، (1388)، بررسی نقش فضایی بازار در ساختار شهرهای ایرانی (با بهرهگیری از روش چیدمان فضا) نمونهی موردی: تبریز کرمان اصفهان تهران، آبادی، شماره 64، 26صص؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟.
14
لینچ، کوین، (1372)، سیمای شهر ، ترجمهی منوچهر مزینی، انتشارات دانشگاه تهران، تهران.
15
محمودی نژاد، هادی؛ آجوک، سوزان؛ تقوایی، علیاکبر؛ انصاری، مجتبی (1386)، جلوگیری از طراحی شهری از طریق طراحی محیطی، فصلنامهی معماری ایران، شمارهی29و30، صص 90-98.
16
مدنی پور، علی (1379)، طراحی فضای شهری: نگرشی بر فرایندی اجتماعی و مکانی، ترجمهی فرهاد مرتضایی، شرکت پردازش و برنامهریزی شهری، تهران.
17
معماریان، غلامحسین (1381)، نحو فضای معماری، صفه، شماره 38 ، صص 75-85.
18
نیومن، اسکار (1394)، خلق فضای قابل دفاع، رواقی، فائزه و صابر، کاوه، انتشارات طحـان، هله، تهران.
19
Bajunid. Anniz Fazli Ibrahim, Mohamed Yusoff Abbas, Abdul Hadi Nawawi, Wan Norhishamuddin Wan Rodi (2014), Cul-de-sac Courtyard Physical Environment Evaluation Toolkit (CPEET), Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, No.153, pp. 148– 158.
20
Chiaradia, A; Hillier, B; Schwander, C & Wedderburn, M (2012), Compositional and urban form effects on centres in Greater London, In Proceedings of the ICE - Urban Design and Planning, Vol. 165(1), pp.21–42.
21
Fisher, B & Nasar, JL (1992), Fear in relation to three site features: Prospect, refuge and escape, Environment and Behavior, 24, pp. 35-62
22
Griz, C & L, Amorim (2015), When luxury is necessary, Apartment projects in Recife – Brazil, Proceedings of the 10th International Space Syntax Symposium, London.
23
Hillier, B (1985), The Nature of the artificials, Geoforum Special Issue on the link between the nature and
24
human sciences, 16, pp.163-178.
25
Hillier, B (2007), Space is the machine: a configurational theory of architecture, Cambridge, University of Cambridge, Reproduced in 2007 by Space Syntax, UK.
26
Hillier, B & Iida, S (2005), Network and psychological effects in urban movement, In Proceedings of Spatial Information Theory: International Conference (Vol. 3693), Ellicottsville, N.Y., U.S.A: Springer-Verlag, pp.475–490.
27
Hillier, B; Chiaradia, A; Hanson, J; Grajewski, T & Xu, J (1993), Natural movement: or, configuration and attraction in urban pedestrian movement, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, Vol. 20, pp.29–66.
28
Hillier, B; Honson, J & Graham, H (1987), Ideas are in things: an Application of space syntax method to
29
discovering house genotype, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 14, pp.363-385.
30
Hillier, B; Honson, J & Peponis, J (1984), What do we mean by building Function?, (E. J. Powell, Ed.)
31
Designing for Building Utilisation, 61-72.
32
Hillier, B; Leaman, A; Stansall, P & Bedford, M (1976), Space Syntax, Environment and Planning B, 3, pp.147-185.
33
Hodgson, P; French, K & Major, R (2007), Avian movement across abrupt ecological edges: Differential
34
responses to housing density in an urban matrix, Landscape and Urban Planning, 79, pp.266–272
35
Hosseini, B; Karimi Azeri, A; Madani, I & Velashani, S (2015), Effect of Physical Factors on the Sense of Security of the People in Isfahan's Traditional Bazaar, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences , 165 – 174, pp.??????????? .
36
Kwon, S & Sailer, K (2015), Seeing and being seen inside a museum and a department store. A comparison study in visibility and co-presence patterns, Proceedings of the 10th International Space syntax Symposium, London.
37
Li, Chen (2008-9), Reinterpretation of Traditional Chinese Courtyard House, Master Theses,University of Tennessee Knoxville,
38
McWilliam, W; Brown, R; Eagles, P & Seasons, M (2014), Barriers to the effective planning and management of residential encroachment within urban forest edges: A Southern Ontario, Canada case study, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 13, pp.48–62.
39
Mustafa, F; Ali, Sanusi & Hassan, Ahmad (2010), Spatial-Functional Analysis of Kurdish Courtyard Houses in Erbil City, American J. of Engineering and Applied Sciences, No.3(3), pp.560-568.
40
Okabe, A & Sugihara, K (2012), Spatial Analysis Along Networks: Statistical and Computational Methods, John Wiley & Sons, ???????????.
41
Oswald, M. J (2011), A Justified Plan Graph Analysis of The Early Houses(1975-1985) of Glem Murcutt,
42
Nexus Network Journal [e-journal], 13 (3), pp. 737-762.
43
Penone, C; Machon, N; Julliard, R & Le Viol, I (2012), Do railway edges provide functional connectivity for plant communities in an urban context?, Biological Conservation, 148, pp.126–133.
44
Peponis, J & Bafna, S & Zhang, Z (2008), The connectivity of streets: reach and directional distance, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, Vol. 35(5), p.881 – 901.
45
Peponis, J; Zimring, C & Choi, Y. K (1990), Finding the building in wayfinding, Environment and
46
Behavior, 22, pp.590-555.
47
Porta, S; Crucitti, P & Latora, V (2006), The Network Analysis of Urban Streets: A Primal Approach, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications, Vol. 369(2), pp.853–866.
48
Smith, N (2014), Beyond top-down/bottom-up:Village transformation on China’s urban edge, Cities, 41, pp. 209–220.
49
Tandy, C.R. V (1967), The Isovist method of landscape survey, in Symposium: Methods of Landscape Analysis Ed( HC Murray) London, Landscape Research Group, pp.9-10.
50
Van Nes, A & López, M (2007), space and crime in dutch built environments: macro and micro scale spatial conditions for residential burglaries and thefts from cars”Proceedings, 6th International Space Syntax Symposium, İstanbul.
51
Varoudis, T & S. Psarra (2014), Beyond two dimensions: Architecture through three-dimensional visibility graph analysis, Journal of space syntax, No.5, pp. 91-108.
52
Weisman, J (1982), Evaluating architectural legibility: way-finding in in the built, Environment and Behavior, March, Vol. 13, pp. 189-20.
53
ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
A Comparative On The Decorative Holy Scrolls Of Mosque MinaretsGohar Shad Mosque and Shah Mashhad
Recognized as the most important religious pillars and centers of urban and rural development in Muslim societies, mosques have, throughout the history of Islamic Architecture, significantly influenced the stylistic and architectural features as well as the development of urban and architectural environments. Accordingly, mosques have often reflected the most prominent and fundamental architectural characteristics of their respective eras. Therefore, careful study of Mosque Minarets Gohar Shad Mosque and Shah Mashhad is undeniably important in revealing these characteristics. The Timurid era is a significant period in the Iranian history in terms of intellectual and religious and cultural developments. During this period, transmigration of artists and craftsmen, particularly architects, from different regions of Iran to Khorasan and Transoxiana led to the revival of artistic/architectural styles in Khorasan after a period of decline. The transmigration was initially forced upon Iranian artists and craftsmen. However, with Khorasan and Transoxiana achieving cultural and economic prosperity during the reigns of King Shahrokh and other Timurid rulers, the artists started migrating to this region voluntarily. Members of the Timurid Royal Family and their high-ranking government officials were active patrons of public works and commissioned the building of many aesthetically and architecturally prominent constructions, among, mosques in particular. The special significance of the Timurid period history is due to religious and cultural developments. so, members of senior government officials built an amazing building. As semantic and decorative elements in the Islamic Architecture, inscriptions were important tools for extending the religious beliefs and policies of the ruling system in different periods. Due to their written form, these elements clearly expressed the prevailing ideas/thoughts of their respective eras. The holy decorations and inscriptions used in different architectural elements of mosques, including Divine Names, Quranic verses, and Islamic hadiths and narratives, have always inspired artists and been regarded as the best examples of Islamic and moral teachings, often being referred to by religious preachers in mosques to guide their congregation. Based on this idea, the holy inscriptions would be aesthetically combined with arabesques of various foliage and geometric patterns as well as central designs (called Toranj or medallion) to display in mosques the most exquisite and thought-provoking examples of Islamic art. As masterpieces of Iranian Islamic architecture and Goharshad and Shah Mosques in Mashhad have been provided with various decorations as well as religious inscriptions (including Divine Names, Quranic verses, and Islamic hadiths and narratives) that reflect the thoughts/ideas of their architects as well as Timurid rulers of the time. In view of this, this study aims to examine these two distinguished Timurid mosques with special emphasis on the adaptability of the holy decorations created on the minarets of these mosques in mashad. The qualitative analytic-comparative methodology was adopted based on the relevant library resources, historical documents, and field observations. Our results revealed that the minarets of the studied mosques had been built in the same historical/architectural period. We also found that the holy decorations on the minarets were highly adaptable in terms of content, color, calligraphy/orthography, Divine Names, and tiling.
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_67908_2aecc7a4577a9bce8767bbb4f27ee62c.pdf
2018-05-22
55
66
10.22059/jfaup.2018.226341.671664
decorations
inscriptions (cornices)
" mosque minaret
" Goharshad Mosque Mashhad
" Shah Mosque Mashhad
Mojtaba
Rezazadeh Ardebili
mrezazdh@.ut.ar.ir
1
Associate Professor Fine Arts College School of architecture University of Tehran
AUTHOR
neda
asadi jafari
neda_architecture@yahoo.com
2
Department of architecture, South Tehran, Branch Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
LEAD_AUTHOR
اثنیعشری، نفیسه و شایستهفر، مهنار (1390)، بررسی نقوش تزیینی قرآنهای تیموری و کاشیکاری مسجد گوهرشاد، مطالعاتهنراسلامی، شمارهی پانزدهم، صص 72-83.
1
احمدی ملکی، ر (1386)، پلههای آسمان، مجله فقه و اصول، شماره 59، صص 4-17.
2
اعتمادالسلطنه، محمدحسنخان (1362)، مطلعشمس، فرهنگسرا، تهران.
3
انوار، قاسم (1337)، کلیاتقاسمانوار، به تصحیح و مقابله و مقدمه سعید نفیسی، کتابخانه سنائی، تهران.
4
اوکین، برنارد (1386)، معماریتیموریدرخراسان، ترجمهی علی آخشینی، بنیاد پژوهشهای اسلامی، مشهد.
5
بلر، شیلا (1382)، هنرومعماریاسلامیدرایرانوآسیایمرکزیدورهایلخانیانوتیموریان، ترجمهی سیدمحمد موسوی هاشمی گلپایگانی، وزارت فرهنگ و ارشاد اسلامی، تهران.
6
بهرامزاده، محمد (1382)، نظریاجمالیبرسیرتحولخطوطاسلامیوخواندنکتیبهها، نیکان کتاب، زنجان.
7
پوپ، آرتور (1374)، معماریایران، ترجمهی کرامتالله افسر، فرهنگسرای یساولی، تهران.
8
پوگاچنکووا، گالینا آناتولیونا (1387)،شاهکارهایمعماریآسیایمیانهسدههایچهاردهموپانزدهممیلادی، ترجمهی سیدداود طبایی، فرهنگستان هنر، تهران.
9
حاجیقاسمی، کامبیز (۱۳۸۲)، فرهنگآثارمعماریاسلامیایران (مساجد)، روزنه، تهران.
10
خواندمیر، غیاثالدین بن همامالدین (1353)، تاریخحبیبالسیر، به اهتمام محمد دبیرسیاقی، انتشارات کتابفروشی خیام، تهران.
11
دانشدوست، یعقوب (۱۳۹۴)، پیدایشباغآسمانیایران، ترجمهی کامران فاضل، کلهر، تهران .
12
زمرشیدی، حسین (1384)، کاشیکاری ایران، سازمان عمران و بهسازی شهری، تهران.
13
سعادت، بیژن (1355)، بارگاهامامرضا: مجموعهمطالعاتیابنیهآستانقدسرضوی، شیراز، انتشارات آسیا، مؤسسهی ایتالیایی، تهران.
14
سیدی، مهدی (1386)، مسجدوموقوفاتگوهرشاد، بنیاد توسعه و پژوهش وقف، تهران.
15
شایستهفر، مهناز (١٣٨١)، بررسی محتوایی کتیبههای مذهبی دوران تیموریان و صفویان، فصلنامه علمی پژوهشی علوم انسانیدانشگاهالزهرا (س)، شماره ٤٣، صص62-111.
16
شایسته فر، مهناز (1389)، بررسی تزیینات و کتیبههای قرآنی دو مجموعه گوهرشاد مشهد و هرات، دوفصلنامهعلمیـپژوهشیمطالعاتهنراسلامی، شماره دوازدهم، صص 73-98.
17
شمس، صادق (1388)، جلوههایی از هنر معماری ایران زمین (واژهنامه سنتی معماری ایران)، علم و دانش، تهران.
18
صحراگرد، مهدی (۱۳۹۲)، شاهکارهایهنریدرآستانقدسرضوی؛کتیبههایمسجدگوهرشاد، مؤسسه آفرینشهای هنری، مشهد.
19
صمدی، حبیبالله (1333)، جامع گوهرشاد یا هشتمین بنای زیبای جهان، یغما، شمارهی 79، صص 509-515.
20
عبدالهی ملائی، شاهرخ (1394)، جستاری در تزیینات معماری اسلامی (مطالعهی موردی: مسجد گوهرشاد مشهد)، در همایشملیمعماریوشهرسازیایرانیـاسلامی، رشت: دانشگاه پیام نور استان گیلان.
21
عطاردی، عزیزالله (۱۳۷۱)، تاریخآستانقدسرضوی، جلد 2، عطارد، تهران.
22
فضائلی، ح. ا (1362)، اطلسخط، مشعل، اصفهان.
23
فغفوری، رباب و بلخاری قهی، حسن (1394)، بررسی تطبیقی مضمون کتیبههای مسجد گوهرشاد و مبانی اعتقادی شیعه در دورهی تیموری و صفوی، نگره، شمارهی 35، صص 4-17.
24
قصابیان، محمدرضا (1384)، مسجد گوهرشاد پس از ششصد سال،مشکوه، شمارهی 86، صص 97-106.
25
کیانی، محمدیوسف (1386)، معماریایران (دورهیاسلامی)، انتشارات مهر، تهران.
26
گرومن، آ (1383)، منشأوتوسعهیابتداییکوفیگلدار، مهناز شایسته فر، مطالعات هنر اسلامی، تهران.
27
مصدقیان طرقبه، وحیده (1384)، رنگونقشدرمسجدگوهرشاد، کتاب آبان، تهران.
28
ملازاده، کاظم و محمدی، مریم (1378)، مساجدتاریخی، پژوهشگاه فرهنگ و هنر اسلامی، تهران .
29
ملازاده، کاظم و محمدی، مریم (1385)، دایرهالمعارفبناهایتاریخیایراندردورهاسلامی، حوزهی هنری سازمان تبلیغات اسلامی، تهران.
30
مولوی، عبدالحمید (1347)، مسجدشاه یا مقبره امیر غیاثالدین ملکشاه، مجله هنرومردم، دوره 7، شماره 74و75، صص75-92.
31
مؤتمن، علی (1348)، تاریخآستانقدسرضوی، بانک ملی، تهران.
32
نجفی، ع (1381)، تحقیقی پیرامون مناره (2)، مکتباسلام، سال 42، شماره 7، صص 60-67.
33
ویلبر، دونالد و گلمبک، لیزا (1374)، معماریتیموریدرایرانوتوران، ترجمهی کرامتالله افسر و محمدیوسف کیانی، سازمان میراث فرهنگی کشور، تهران.
34
هیلنبراند، رابرت (1391)، هنرومعماریاسلامی، روزنه، تهران.
35
ییت، چارلز ادوارد (1369)، خراسانوسیستان،سفرنامهکلنلییتبهایرانوافغانستان، ترجمهی قدرتالله روشنی و مهرداد رهبری، یزدان، تهران.
36
http://parsacity.com
37
http://www.negahmedia.ir
38
ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
The history of public mentalities as an influential factor on the quality of housing
Today, there is a separation between the mentality of residents and buildings in the quality of residential constructions. This is due to factors such as the rise of modernity, the increasing population and urbanization along with the complexity of the relationship between the employer, the designer, and the user, the development of singularity, and quantity-oriented approach to residential environments. The history of public mentalities through the use of memory tool is a kind of interface between our subjectivities and their representations in the residential environments. This representation sometimes monitors the problem of meaning and sometimes reveals an identity or structure and thus influences all three dimensions of the quality of residential environments including micro, medium, and macro scale. At a micro scale, internal relations among residential units, at a medium scale, neighborhood relations among units and at a macro scale, relations between a complex and city are considered. By this assumption, this research seeks to answer the following question: What has changed the history of popular housing in the present time compared to the past in Zanjan? To this end, interviews were initially conducted with two groups of residents of new apartments and those living traditional and old constructions. Then, by analyzing the content, the main categories regarding the history of public mentalities were extracted from both groups. To test the reliability and generalizability of the categories to Zanjan, we tested them through a quantitative study. The results of the research indicate that the identity layer in all three scales of modern apartments is weak compared to old ones and therefore, today's mindset about the quality of housing is an individualistic and introverted subjectivity. However, in traditional houses, communication with other residents of the neighborhood and the city is always prioritized. This leads to the formation of a collective mentality. On the other hand, today, the physical, functional, and visual perspicacity of the interior spaces and houses receives top priority. Therefore, the history of today's mentality is somewhat more in the face of visualization, consumerism, and aesthetics (from a purely visual point of view) than it was in the past. Also, due to the weakening of today's houses, the importance of religion has diminished whilst the ancient houses were based on faith and religion, and portrayed a story of priority for credibility and pragmatism. Nowadays, environmental designers, planners, architects, etc., have to make the necessary assessments and implement them based on the findings of the research and take advantage of these rich traditional architectural teachings to find solutions to the problem. It is clear that the solution to this problem, in addition to the need for a change in the physical patterns, requires discussion of culture and change in the way of history and the history of public mentality. Thus, it is hoped that the path could be redirected while referring to the fundamental categories of human needs in the public domain in the sense of habitation in an interactive pattern of behavior.
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_67909_7cebda57b0e886d572ffbeefe4720aed.pdf
2018-05-22
67
80
10.22059/jfaup.2018.238201.671763
Quality
habitation
History of public mentalities
Memory
Zanjan City
minou
gharehbaglou
minoo_gha@yahoo.com
1
architecture & urbanisim faculty, Tabriz Islamic art university
LEAD_AUTHOR
Solmaz
Roohifar
s71.rohifar@gmail.com
2
architecture group, Architecture and Urbanism Faculty, Tabriz Islamic Art University, Tabriz, Iran
AUTHOR
برک، پیتر (1389)، تاریخ فرهنگی چیست؟، ترجمه نعمت الله فاضلی و مرتضی قلیچ، انتشارات پژوهشکده تاریخ اسلام، تهران.
1
برگر، پبیتر؛ برگر، بریجیت (1394)، ذهن بی خانمان (نوسازی و آگاهی)، ترجمه محمد ساوجی، نشر نی، تهران.
2
پوردیهیمی، شهرام (1394)، منظر انسانی در محیط مسکونی، نشر آرمانشهر، تهران.
3
تابان، محسن؛ پورجعفر، محمدرضا؛ پورمند، حسنعلی (1391)، هویت و مکان؛ رویکردی پدیدارشناسانه، هویت شهر، شماره 10، صص 90 – 79.
4
تامپسون، ادوارد پالمر (1396)، تکوین طبقه کارگر در انگلستان، ترجمه محمد مالجو، انتشارات آگاه، تهران.
5
جعفری نجف آبادی، عاطفه؛ مهدوی پور، حسین (1392)، نقش تکنولوژی های بومی در کیفیت فضاهای مسکونی، مسکن و محیط روستا، شماره 141، صص 68 – 51.
6
ذکایی، محمد سعید(1390)، مطالعات فرهنگی و مطالعات حافظه، نشریه مطالعات اجتماعی ایران، دوره ۵، شماره ۳، صص ۷۲ - ۹۶
7
راپاپورت، آموس (1388)، انسان شناسی مسکن، ترجمه خسرو افضلیان، انتشارات حرفه هنرمند، تهران.
8
سولسو، رابرت (1381)، روانشناسی شناختی، ترجمه فرهاد ماهر، انتشارات رشد، تهران.
9
سیدمن، اروینک (1395)، مصاحبه به عنوان یک روش پژوهش کیفی؛ راهنمای پژوهشگران علوم تربیتی، اجتماعی و انسانی، ترجمه علی کوشا زاده، علیرضا جابری و سارا حسینی ارانی، انتشارات مهکامه، تهران.
10
شارتیه، روژه (1377)، تاریخ فرهنگی؛ رابطه فلسفه و تاریخ، ترجمه حسین علی نوذری، تاریخ معاصر ایران، شماره 6، صص 130 – 101.
11
شایگان، داریوش (1395)، در جستجوی فضاهای گم شده، نشر فرهنگ معاصر، تهران.
12
عادل مهربان، مرضیه (1394)، مروری بر تحلیل محتوای کیفی و کاربرد آن در پژوهش، انتشارات دانشگاه علوم پزشکی و خدمات بهداشتی درمانی استان اصفهان، اصفهان.
13
عاملی، سعیدرضا (1390)، مطالعات جهانی شدن: دو فضایی شدن ها و دو جهانی شدن ها، انتشارات سمت، تهران.
14
عاملی، سید سعیدرضا؛ اخوان، منیژه(1391). بازنمایی عناصر هویت بخش در سفرنامه ها (مطالعه مقایسه ای تهران و شهرستان های استان تهران)، مطالعات و تحقیقات اجتماعی در ایران، شماره 4، صص 100 – 75.
15
عینی فر، علیرضا (1379)، عوامل انسانی – محیطی موثر در طراحی مجموعه های مسکونی، هنرهای زیبا، شماره 8، صص 118 – 109.
16
فاضلی، نعمت الله (1393)، تاریخ فرهنگی ایران مدرن، انتشارات پژوهشگاه علوم انسانی و مطالعات فرهنگی، تهران.
17
فکوهی، ناصر (1383)، انسان شناسی شهری، نشر نی، تهران.
18
قیومی بیدهندی، مهرداد (1390)، گفتارهایی در مبانی و تاریخ معماری و هنر، انتشارت علمی و فرهنگی، تهران.
19
قیومی بیدهندی، مهرداد؛ شمس، امید (1391)، درآمدی بر تاریخ ذهنیت عامه در معماری ایران، مطالعات معماری ایران، شماره 2، صص 25 – 5.
20
گروت، لیندا؛ وانگ، دیوید (1386)، روش های تحقیق در معماری، ترجمه علیرضا عینی فر، انتشارات دانشگاه تهران، تهران.
21
گلیجانی مقدم، نسرین(1384)، تاریخ شناسی معماری ایران، انتشارات دانشگاه تهران، تهران.
22
لنگ، جان (1383)، آفرینش نظریه معماری: نقش علوم رفتاری در طراحی محیط، ترجمه علیرضا عینی فر، انتشارات دانشگاه تهران، تهران.
23
لینچ، کوین (1376)، تئوری شکل خوب شهر، ترجمه سید حسین بحرینی، انتشارات دانشگاه تهران، تهران.
24
مناف زاده، علیرضا (1369)، ذهنیت و تاریخ، ایران نامه، شماره 32، صص 588 – 567.
25
ون پل، ریک (1390)، رویکردها و روش های سنجش کیفیت محیط مسکونی شهری، ترجمه مجتبی رفیعیان و جمشید مولودی، انتشارات آذرخش، تهران.
26
هال، جان (1389)، تاریخ فرهنگی، ترجمه عباس احمدوند، کتاب ماه تاریخ و جغرافیا، شماره 144، صص 26 – 24.
27
Ankersmit, F. R (1994), History & Tropology, The Rise & Fall of Metaphor, University of California Press, Berkeley.
28
Assmann, J (2008), Communicative and Cultural Memory, In A. Erll, A. Nunning (Ed) Cultural Memory Studies, Walter De Gruyter, Berlin.
29
Burke, P (1986), Strengths & Weaknesses of the History of Mentalities, History of European Ideas, Vol 7, No 5, pp. 439 – 451.
30
Burke, P (1998), Mentalities. In A Global Encyclopedia of Historical Writing: K – Z, ed. D. R. Woolf. Taylor & Francis.
31
Certeau, M (1984), The Practice of Everyday Life, University of California Press, Berkely.
32
Clark, J, Kearns, A (2012), Housing Improvements, Perceived Housing Quality and Psychosocial Benefits From the Home, Housing Studies, Vol 27, No 7, pp. 915 – 939.
33
Crosby, P. B (1980), Quality Is Free: The Art of Making Quality Certain, Mentor, New York.
34
Gifford, R (1997), Environmental Psychology: Principles and Practice, University of California Press, Berkeley.
35
Gruyter, W (2008), Cultural Memory Studies, Media & Cultural Memory: An International & Interdisciplinary Handbook, In A. Erll, A. Nunning (Ed), New York.
36
Hutton, P. H (1981), The History of Mentalities: The New Map of Cultural History, History and Theory, Vol 20, No 3, pp. 237 – 259.
37
Hutton, P. H (1999), Mentalities, History of. In Encyclopedia of Historians & Historical Writing, ed. Kelly Boyd. Fitzroy Dearborn.
38
Juran, J. M (1989), Juran on Leadership for Quality: An Executive Handbook, Free Press, New York.
39
Kesalkheh, S, Dadashpoor, H (2012), Assessment Residential Environmental Quality of Traditional and New Neighborhoods, in a Rapid Grown City , New and Traditional Residential Environments 48th ISOCARP Congress, Tehran.
40
Ladurie, E. B, Daedalus. S. R (1977), Recent Historical Discoveries, Discoveries & Interpretations: Studies In Contemporary Scholarship, No 4, pp. 141 – 155.
41
Lansing, J. B, Marans, R.W (1969), Evaluation of Neighborhood, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, No 35, pp. 195 – 199.
42
Montgomery, D .C (2005), Introduction to Statistical Quality Control, John Wiley & Sons Inc, Printed in the USA, Arizona state university.
43
Nasar, J (1994), Urban Design Aesthetics – The Evaluative Qualities of Building Exterior, Environment & Behavior, No 26, Pp. 377 - 401.
44
Olson, Eric T (2002), Personal Identity, in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Edward N. Zalta, ed. URL= http://plato. stanford.edu/archives / fall2002/ entries/ identity-personal /. 2002
45
Porteous, J. D (1971), Design With People: The Quality of the Urban Environment, City Planning, No 2, pp. 155 – 178.
46
Rao, R. P. N (2003), Attention, Models of. In L. Nadel (Ed), Encyclopedia of Cognitive Science, Nature Publishing Group, London, pp. 231 – 237.
47
Rossi, A (1982), Architecture of the City, MIT Press, Cambridge.
48
Taguchi, T (2006), Welsh Nationalism and Cultural Identity, Journal of Culture and Information Science, 1 (1), pp.1-7.
49
Vezzoni, C (2007), Components of National Identity, University of Milan, Milan.
50
Wright, P. D (2003), A Theoretical Overview of Memory and Conflict in Cairns, Ed & Roe, Michael D, The Role of Memory in Ethnic Conflict, Palgrave, pp. 9 – 35.
51
ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
Life cycle assessment of a real residential building in Tehran
Among many aspects considered to evaluate the low energy buildings, the Life Cycle Energy Consumption (LCEC) is the most comprehensive factor that can properly direct engineers and architectures to the buildings’ optimum design. The LCEC is introduced as the total energy usage associated with all stages of a building’s life cycle mainly consists of production of its materials, transportation of the materials and components, on-site construction, operation, maintenance, demolition and waste treatment. This study aims to evaluate the LCEC factor of a real building located in Tehran, Iran. Due to the lack of the investigations in this field in Iran, the methodology of estimating the building’s energy consumption is comprehensively introduced in this paper. For this purpose, a real multi-family residential building with common architectural plan and residences is selected and the process of evaluating the building’s energy consumption during various periods of its life cycle is discussed in detail. These periods include the material production, transportation, on-site construction, operation, and maintenance stage. Demolition and disposal stage is excluded from the scope of this study because of the lack of the clear information about the waste treatment process in the country. Beside, the energy usage of this stage is reported to be less than 1% of the buildings’ total LCEC according to the literature. The results of this analysis show that the embodied energy of the considered case is about 15% of its LCEC. This embodied energy that is indeed in the range of the internationally reported values can be divided into three separate parts including: 1) 12% energy usage for the building material production, 2) 1% energy usage for the material transportation and on-site construction, and 3) 2% energy consumption for the building maintenance stage. In this regard, it seems that the energy usage during on-site construction period of the building has the minimum effect on the building’s LCEC (about 0.2%) and consequently may be ignored in the LCEC process. It is also concluded that 85% of the considered building’s LCEC belongs to the operation stage in which the effect of climate change in terms of global warming is considered via a simple method based on the change of the thermal comfort setpoints. Although this operational energy is in the range of the values reported in the common international investigations, it is too high for Iran where the lifespan of the residential buildings is respectively short. If the lifespan of the considered building in this study increase from 35 years to 60 years, the portion of the operational energy can increase up to 91% of the building’s LCEC. Therefore, proper estimation of the building’s lifespan is demanded for most of the energy assessment studies. Accurate estimation of the energy content of the building materials in Iran is also highly necessitated. If the material production industry in Iran consumes averagely 30% more energy respect to the average values of the world’s industry, the building’s operational energy will reduce about 3% and respectively its total embodied energy will increase about the same amount.
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_67910_d6da1101a4dcd818f5903106532e9002.pdf
2018-05-22
81
92
10.22059/jfaup.2018.247936.671899
Life Cycle
Energy consumption
Residential building
Concrete frame
Embodied energy
Iran
Fatemeh
Yousefi
f.yousefi5@gmail.com
1
Department of Construction Engineering and Management, Civil Engineering School, University of Tehran
LEAD_AUTHOR
Yaghob
Gholipour
ygholipour@ut.ac.ir
2
Engineering Optimization Research Gr., School of Civil Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
AUTHOR
حیدری، شاهین (1388)، دمای آسایش حرارتی مردم شهر تهران، نشریه هنرهای زیبا-معماری و شهرسازی، شماره 38، صص 14-5.
1
فروزان نرجس؛ حاجی پور، خلیل و سلطانی، علی (1395)، بررسی مصرف انرژی نهفته در بافت های مسکونی : نمونه موردی شهر شیراز، فصلنامه علمی پژوهشی نقش جهان، فصل 6، شماره 1، صص 52-42.
2
قربانی، خلیل (1393)، الگوی فصلی و مکانی تغییر اقلیم دمای هوا در ایران، نشریه پژوهش های حفاظت آب و خاک، جلد 21، شماره 5، صص 270-257.
3
مرکز آمار ایران (1391- تابستان 1395)، اطلاعات پروانه های ساختمانی صادرشده توسط شهرداری های کشور، تهران، دفتر ریاست، روابط عمومی و همکاری های بین الملل.
4
Adalbert, K (1997), Energy use during the life cycle of single-unit dwellings:examples, Building and Environment , Vol. 32, No. 4, pp. 321-329.
5
Crowther, P (1999), Design for disassembly to recover embodied energy, in The 16th International Conference on Passive and Low Energy Architecture, Melbourne–Brisbane–Cairns.
6
Deng, W; Prasad, D; Osmond P & Li, F (2011), Quantifying life cycle energy and carbon footprints of China's residential small district, Journal of Green Building, Vol. 6, No. 4, pp. 96-111.
7
Dixit, M; Fernández-Solís, J; Lavy, S & Culp C (2010), Identification of parameters for embodied energy measurement: A literature review, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 42, No. 8, pp. 1238-1247.
8
Dixit, M; Culp, C & Fernández-Solís, J (2013), System boundary for embodied energy in buildings: A conceptual model for definition, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 21, pp. 153-164.
9
Dixit, M; Culp, C; Lavy S & Fernández-Solís, J (2014), Recurrent embodied energy and its relationship with service life and life cycle energy: A review paper, Facilities, Vol. 32, No. 3/4, pp.160-181.
10
Dixit, M (2017), Life cycle embodied energy analysis of residential buildings: A review of literature to investigate embodied energy parameters, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Vol. 79, pp. 390-413.
11
Gao, W; Ariyama, T; Ojima, T & Meier, A (2001), Energy impacts of recycling disassembly material in residential buildings, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 33, pp. 553-562.
12
Hammond G & Jones, C (2008), Inventory of Carbon and Energy (ICE), Sustainable Energy Research Team, Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, University of Bath, Bath, United Kingdom.
13
Heravi, G; Nafisi T & Mousavi, R (2016), Evaluation of energy consumption during production andconstruction of concrete and steel frames of residential buildings, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 130, pp. 244-252.
14
Junnila, S; Horvath A & Guggemos, A (2006), Life-cycle assessment of office buildings in Europe and the United States, Journal of Infrastructure Systems , Vol. 12, No. 1, pp. 10-17, 2006.
15
Koocheki, A; Nasiri, M; Kamali, G. A; & Shahandeh, H (2006 ), Potential Impacts of Climate Change on Agroclimatic Indicators in Iran, Arid Land Research and Management, Vol. 20, No. 3, pp. 245-259.
16
Kotaji , S; Edwards S & Schuurmans, A (2003), Life cycle assessment in building and construction, A state-of-the-Art report, SETAC press, ?????????.
17
Kua, H & Wong, C (2012), Analysing the life cycle greenhouse gas emission and energy consumption of a multi-storied commercial building in Singapore from an extended system boundry perspective, Energy and buildings,??????????? pp. 6-14.
18
Lelieveld, J; Hadjinicolaou, P; Kostopoulou, E; Chenoweth, J; Maayar, M. El; Giannakopoulos, C; Hannides, C; Lange, M. A; Tanarhte, M; Tyrlis, E & Xoplaki, E (2012), Climate change and impacts in the Eastern Mediterranean and the Middle East, Climatic Change, Vol 114, pp. 667–687.
19
Ma, J; Du, G; Zhang, Z; Wang P & Xie, B (2017), Life cycle analysis of energy consumption and CO2 emissions from a typical large offi ce building in Tianjin , China, building and Environment, Vol. 117, pp. 36-48.
20
Metasd (2008), [Online]. Available: http://metasd.com/2008/08/climate-war-game-is-2050-temperature-locked-in/. [Accessed 22 10 2017].
21
Mithraratne N & Vale, B (2004), Life cycle analysis model for New Zeland houses, Building and Environment,???????????? pp. 483-492.
22
Nassen, J; Holmberg, J; Wadeskog A & Nyman, M (2007), Direct and indirect energy use and carbon emissions in the production phase of buildings: An input output analysis, Energy, Vol. 32, No. 9, pp. 1593-1602.
23
Nassen, J; Hedenus, F; Karlsson S & Holmberg, J (2012), Concrete vs. wood in buildings- an energy system approach, Building and environment, Vol. 51,pp. 361-369.
24
Peuportier, B (2001), Life cycle assessment applied to the comparative evaluation of single family houses in the French context, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 33, No. 5, pp. 443-450.
25
Praseeda, K; Venkatarama Reddy B & Mani, M (2016), Embodied and operational energy of urban residentialbuildings in India, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 110, pp. 211-219.
26
Pullen, S (2000), Energy used in the construction and operation of houses, Architectural Science Review, Vol. 43, No. 2, pp. 87-94.
27
Ramesh, T; Prakash R & Shukla, K. K (2010), Life cycle energy analysis of buildings: an overview, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 42, pp. 1592-1600.
28
Ramesh, T; Prakash R & Shukla, K. K (2013), Life cycle energy analysis of a multifamily residential house: a case study in Indian context, Journal of Energy Efficiency, Vol. 2, pp. 34-41.
29
Roshan, Gh. R; Ranjbar, F & Orosa, A (2010), Simulation of global warming effect on outdoor thermal comfort conditions, International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 571-580.
30
Thormark, C (2002), A low energy building in a life cycle—its embodied energy, energy need for operation and recycling potential, Building and Environment, Vol. 37, pp. 429 – 435.
31
Venkatarama Reddy, B & Jagadish, K (2003), Embodied energy of common and alternative building materials and technologies, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 35 , pp. 129–137.
32
Vukotic, L; Fenner, R & Symons, K (2010), Assessing embodied energy of building structural elements, in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Engineering Sustainability, Vol. 163, No. 3, pp. 147-158, Thomas Telford Ltd.
33
Winter, B & Hestnes, A (1999), Solar versus green: The analysis of a Norwegian row house, Solar Energy, Vol. 66, No. 6, pp. 387–393.
34
Yousefi, F; Gholipour Y & Yan, W (2017), A study of the impact of occupant behaviors on energy performance of building envelopes using occupants’ data, Energy & Buildings, Vol. 148, pp. 182-198.
35
ORIGINAL_ARTICLE
Analyze of an educational experience at courses of architecture in first year of education
(referring to nature in case of sunflower exercise)
This written is going to express and analyze an educational experience during first-year of architecture which had been referenced to elements of nature as complete design patterns. The research method is descriptive-analytical and it is operational and based on case study which examined several semesters by different students and different natural elements. The case study, had been done in department of Architecture and Urban planning at Shahid Beheshti University. In case study, the research based on observation and understanding natural elements, study of architecture cases referenced to nature during visiting places and library studying. In case of sunflower consequence exercise, the process starts from exact observation, deep discovering and complicated origins during hand drawing of the sunflower by first-year architecture students. They compared their finding as drawing by samples of geometry in architecture cases which referenced to sunflower. They have found that the geometry of sunflower has been simplified to some extent to be easy to be used in buildings. Also they said besides the geometry had been simplified, the cases reflected nature reference which was sunflower. The process was being continued by how the rules and results of discovering could be used to design needs of students in studio. The students realized that the geometry gained from sunflower has a center oriented property and it has symmetry so it should be used to build something which needs focus on center. The volumes which students have started to build was a hanging ceiling to corridor which ends to their studio. After that choosing material and way of making something by students would be followed. The chosen materials were balsa wood and woolen. The handmade ceiling was built by 11 students. Students studio had 3 ones which were different from each other but each of them refers to sunflower. In result, it could be said that focus on nature as rich origin to be referenced by architecture students has advantages such as: encourage students to exact observation, approach to intellectual beauty, richness of analyzing, creating entrance to creation, attraction of doing in team-work, entrance to geometry and hand-made in real scale. In other hand, as feedbacks of the case exercise it must be said that such process are suitable to first-year of architecture education and they can cause to express the hidden affordances of students. The challenges which teachers are encountered by are that guiding students in such process is different and hard to some extent Because the background of students is not adapted to team-work and operational exercise. In other word, the students are not prepared to do observation in exact way to understand nature. In other hand, doing these exercises is time consuming. Also different natural elements differ to each other to understand their hidden geometry. Finally, it should be said that being in process to find origins of natural creations to create for design needs of first year architecture students is an old and responsive strategy. But, the limitation by such exercises is being surrounded by only form derived from it is not enough useful for architecture students.
https://jfaup.ut.ac.ir/article_67911_eaff458ba5791b84771c3511cd3d624c.pdf
2018-05-22
93
104
10.22059/jfaup.2018.254350.671985
referring to nature
architecture exercise
first-year courses
Sunflower
hidden geometry
to find origins
Azadeh
Khaki Ghasr
azadehkhaki@gmail.com
1
Department of Architecture and Urban Planning, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
LEAD_AUTHOR
Hossein
Pour Mehdi Ghayem Maghami
hpourmehdi85@gmail.com
2
department of architecture and urban planning, shahid beheshti university, tehran, iran
AUTHOR
ثقفی، محمودرضا؛ مظفر، فرهنگ و موسوی، سیدمحسن(۱۳۹۴)، بررسی تاثیر روش آموزش مشارکت مستقیم استاد و دانشجو بر فرایند یادگیری در درس مقدمات طراحی معماری ۱،دوفصلنامه علمی-پژوهشی مرمت و معماری ایران، سال پنجم، شماره دهم، صص۹۰-۷۹.
1
حجت، عیسی و انصاری، حمیدرضا (۱۳۸۹)، بازاندیشی در رفتارهای آموزشی معماری بر پایه آسیب شناسی آموزش متوسطه، نشریه هنرهای زیبا- معماری و شهرسازی، شماره ۴۴، صص۲۵-۱۵.
2
دکزی، گیورگی(۱۳۸۸)، ناکرانمندی کرانمند(جستاری در تناسبات طبیعت، هنر و معماری)، مترجم: حمیدرضا کرمی، با پیشگفتار محمد ضیمران، چاپ اول، انتشارات پرچین، تهران.
3
سالینگروس، نیکاس آنجلوس(۱۳۸۷)، یک نظریه معماری، ترجمه: سعید زرین مهر و زهیر متکی، مرکز مطالعاتی و تحقیقاتی شهرسازی و معماری
4
شورای عالی برنامه ریزی وزارت علوم، گروه هنر(۱۳۷۷)، مشخصات کلی، برنامه و سرفصل دروس دوره کارشناسی مهندسی معماری، وزارت علوم، تحقیقات و فناوری، تهران.
5
غریب پور، افرا و توتونچی مقدم، مارال(۱۳۹۴)، بازنگری تطبیقی برنامه آموزشی پایه طراحی در دوره کارشناسی معماری، نشریه هنرهای زیبا-معماری و شهرسازی، دوره ۲۰، شماره ۴، صص ۷۲-۵۹.
6
قارونی اصفهانی، فاطمه(۱۳۹۴)، معماری بایونیک:طراحی طبیعت، چاپ اول، انتشارات مولف ، تهران.
7
محمودی، سیدامیرسعید(۱۳۷۷)، آموزش روند طراحی معماری: بکارگیری استعدادهای نهفته دانشجویان، نشریه هنرهای زیبا، شماره ۴و ۵، زمستان ۱۳۷۷، صص ۸۱-۷۳.
8
ندیمی، حمید(۱۳۸۹)، روش استاد و شاگردی از نگاهی دیگر، نشریه هنرهای زیبا- معماری و شهرسازی، شماره ۴۴، صص۳۶-۲۷.
9
ندیمی، هادی(۱۳۷۰)، مدخلی بر روشهای آموزش معماری، نشریه صفه، سال دوم، شماره دوم، صص؟؟؟؟.
10
نیک کار، محمد؛ حجت، عیسی و ایزدی، عباسعلی(۱۳۹۲)، بررسی سازه هدف و کاربست آن در ایجاد انگیزش در نوآموز معماری، دوفصلنامه مطالعات معماری ایرانی، شماره ۳، صص ۱۰۶-۸۵.
11
Carlson, Lawrence E and Sullivan, Jacquelyn F (1999), Hands-on Engineering: Learning by Doing in the Integrated Teaching and Learning Program, Int. J. Engng Ed, Vol. 15, No. 1, pp. 20-31.
12
Gustafsson, Göran; Newman, Dava J; Stafström, Stafström, Sven & Wallin, Hans Peter(2014), First-year introductory courses as a means to develop conceive – design – implement – operate skills in engineering education programmes, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228969045 آخرین دسترسی به سایت ۸/۱۱/۱۳۹۶ .
13
Jacques Grillo, Paul (1975), Form Function & Design, Dover Publications, Inc., New York.
14
Knippers, Jan and Speck, Thomas (2012), Design and construction principles in nature and architecture, Bioinspirationd & Biomimetics Journal, ??????????IOP Publishing.
15
Mac Namara, Sinead C (2012), Bringing Engineering into the studio: Design assignment for teaching structures to architects, American Society for Engineering Education.
16
Wu, Yun-Wu; Weng, Kuo-Hua &Young, Li-Ming (2016), A Concept Transformation Learning Model for Architectural Design Learning Process, Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science & Technology Education, 12(5), 1189-1197.
17